Unclaimed listing. Own this business? Claiming opens soon.
Caribbean Pie Company
Key lime pie specialist in Sarasota making silky, tart pies with graham cracker crust for over 35 years.
About
Caribbean Pie Company has been making key lime pie in Sarasota since the late 1980s. Their signature pie features a silky smooth filling with bright tartness and a golden graham cracker crust. If you want pie on the go, they offer a hand-held version on a stick. Beyond the shop, they rent out a distinctive green-and-white dessert cart for weddings, corporate events, festivals, and parties; the cart keeps desserts cold without needing electricity. You can also find their pies at local farmers markets around Sarasota and Southwest Florida.